Even
on a stiflingly hot summer's day, the Athens underground is a pleasure.
It is air-conditioned, with plasma screens to entertain passengers
relaxing in cool, cavernous departure halls - and the trains even run
on time. There is another bonus for users of this state-of-the-art
rapid transport system: it is, in effect, free for the five million
people of the Greek capital. With no barriers to prevent free entry or
exit to this impressive tube network, the good citizens of Athens are
instead asked to 'validate' their tickets at honesty machines before
boarding. Few bother. This
is not surprising: fiddling on a Herculean scale — from the owner of
the smallest shop to the most powerful figures in business and politics
— has become as much a part of Greek life as ouzo and olives. Indeed,
as well as not paying for their metro tickets, the people of Greece
barely paid a penny of the underground’s £1.5 billion cost — a
‘sweetener’ from Brussels (and, therefore, the UK taxpayer) to help the
country put on an impressive 2004 Olympics free of the city’s notorious
traffic jams. The
transport perks are not confined to the customers. Incredibly, the
average salary on Greece’s railways is £60,000, which includes cleaners
and track workers - treble the earnings of the average private sector
employee here. The overground rail network is as big a racket as the EU-funded underground. While its annual income is only £80 million
from ticket sales, the wage bill is more than £500m a year — prompting
one Greek politician to famously remark that it would be cheaper to put
all the commuters into private taxis. ‘We
have a railroad company which is bankrupt beyond comprehension,’ says
Stefanis Manos, a former Greek finance minister. ‘And yet, there isn’t
a single private company in Greece with that kind of average
pay.’ Significantly, since entering Europe as part of an ill-fated
dream by politicians of creating a European super-state, the wage bill
of the Greek public sector has doubled in a decade. At the same time,
perks and fiddles reminiscent of Britain in the union-controlled 1970s
have flourished. Ridiculously,
Greek pastry chefs, radio announcers, hairdressers and masseurs in
steam baths are among more than 600 professions allowed to retire at 50
(with a state pension of 95 per cent of their last working year’s
earnings) — on account of the ‘arduous and perilous’ nature of their
work. This
week, it was reported that every family in Britain could face a £14,000
bill to pay for Greece’s self-inflicted financial crisis. Such fears
were denied yesterday after Brussels voted a massive new £100bn rescue
package which, it insisted, would not need a contribution from Britain. Even
if this is true — and many British MPs have their doubts — we will
still have to stump up £1billion to the bailout through the
International Monetary Fund. In
return for this loan, European leaders want the Greeks’ free-spending
ways to end immediately if the country is to be prevented from
‘infecting’ the world’s financial system. Naturally, the Greek people
are not happy about this. In
Constitution Square this week, opposite the parliament, I witnessed
thousands gathering to campaign against government cuts designed to
save the country from bankruptcy. After
running battles with riot police, who used tear gas to disperse
protesters, thousands are still camped out in the square ahead of a
vote by Greek politicians next week on whether to accept Europe-imposed
austerity measures. Yet
these protesters should direct their anger closer to home — to those
Greeks who have for many years done their damndest to deny their
country the dues they owe it. Take a short trip on the metro to the city’s cooler northern suburbs, and you will find an enclave of staggering opulence. Here,
in the suburb of Kifissia, amid clean, tree-lined streets full of
designer boutiques and car showrooms selling luxury marques such as
Porsche and Ferrari, live some of the richest men and women in the
world. With
its streets paved with marble, and dotted with charming parks and
cafes, this suburb is home to shipping tycoons such as Spiros Latsis, a
billionaire and friend of Prince Charles, as well as countless other
wealthy industrialists and politicians. One
of the reasons they are so rich is that rather than paying millions in
tax to the Greek state, as they rightfully should, many of these
residents are living entirely tax-free. Along
street after street of opulent mansions and villas, surrounded by high
walls and with their own pools, most of the millionaires living here
are, officially, virtually paupers. How
so? Simple: they are allowed to state their own earnings for tax
purposes, figures which are rarely challenged. And rich Greeks take
full advantage. Astonishingly,
only 5,000 people in a country of 12 million admit to earning more than
£90,000 a year — a salary that would not be enough to buy a garden shed
in Kifissia. Yet
studies have shown that more than 60,000 Greek homes each have
investments worth more than £1m, let alone unknown quantities in
overseas banks, prompting one economist to describe Greece as a ‘poor
country full of rich people’. Manipulating
a corrupt tax system, many of the residents simply say that they earn
below the basic tax threshold of around £10,000 a year, even though
they own boats, second homes on Greek islands and properties overseas. And,
should the taxman rumble this common ruse, it can be dealt with using a
‘fakelaki’ — an envelope stuffed with cash. There is even a
semi-official rate for bribes: passing a false tax return requires a
payment of up to 10,000 euros (the average Greek family is reckoned to
pay out £2,000 a year in fakelaki.) Even
more incredibly, Greek shipping magnates — the king of kings among the
wealthy of Kifissia — are automatically exempt from tax, supposedly on
account of the great benefits they bring the country. Yet
the shipyards are empty; once employing 15,000, they now have less than
500 to service the once-mighty Greek shipping lines which, like the
rest of the country, are in terminal decline. With
Greek President George Papandreou calling for a crackdown on these tax
dodgers — who are believed to cost the economy as much as £40bn a year
— he is now resorting to bizarre means to identify the cheats. After
issuing warnings last year, government officials say he is set to
deploy helicopter snoopers, along with scrutiny of Google Earth
satellite pictures, to show who has a swimming pool in the northern
suburbs — an indicator, officials say, of the owner’s wealth. Officially,
just over 300 Kifissia residents admitted to having a pool. The true
figure is believed to be 20,000. There is even a boom in sales of
tarpaulins to cover pools and make them invisible to the aerial tax
inspectors. ‘The
most popular and effective measure used by owners is to camouflage
their pool with a khaki military mesh to make it look like natural
undergrowth,’ says Vasilis Logothetis, director of a major swimming
pool construction company. ‘That way, neither helicopters nor Google
Earth can spot them.’ But
faced with the threat of a crackdown, money is now pouring out of the
country into overseas tax havens such as Liechtenstein, the Bahamas and
Cyprus. Parliament:
It could be all over for Greece, which is effectively bust from relying
on EU cash from richer northern European countries ‘Other
popular alternatives include setting up offshore companies in Cyprus or
the British Virgin Islands, or the purchase of real estate abroad,’
says one doctor, who declares an income of less than £90,000 yet earns
five times that amount. There
has also been a boom in London property purchases by Athens-based
Greeks in an attempt to hide their true worth from their domestic tax
authorities. ‘These
anti-tax evasion measures by the government force us to resort to even
more detailed tax evasion ploys,’ admits Petros Iliopoulos, a civil
engineer. Hotlines
have been set up offering rewards for people who inform on tax dodgers.
Last month, to show the government is serious, it named and shamed 68
high-earning doctors found guilty of tax evasion. ‘We
will spare no effort to collect what is due to the state,’ said
Evangelos Venizelos, the new Greek finance minister of the socialist
ruling party. ‘We promise to draft and apply a new and honest tax
system, one that has been needed for decades, so that taxes are duly
paid by those who should pay.’ Yet,
already, it is too late. Greece is effectively bust — relying on EU
cash from richer northern European countries, but this has been the
case ever since the country finally joined the euro in 2001. Two years earlier, the country was barred from entering because it did not meet the financial criteria. No
matter: the Greeks simply cooked the books. Two years later, having
falsely claimed to have met standards relating to manufacturing and
industrial production and low inflation, the Greeks were allowed in. Funds poured into the country from across Europe and the Greeks started spending like there was no tomorrow. Money
flowed into all areas of public life. As a result, for example, the
Greek school system is now an over-staffed shambles, employing four
times more teachers per pupil than Finland, the country with the
highest-rated education system in Europe. ‘But we still have to pay for
tutors for our two children,’ says Helena, an Athens mother. ‘The
teachers are hopeless — they seem to spend their time off sick.’ Although
Brussels has now agreed to provide the next stage of its debt payment
programme to safeguard the country’s immediate economic future, the
Greek media still carries ominous warnings that the military may be
forced to step in should the country’s foray into Europe end in
ignominy, bankruptcy and rising violence. For
now, the crisis has simply been delayed. With European taxpayers facing
the prospect of saving Greece from bankruptcy for the second year in a
row, some say even the £100bn on offer will pay off only the interest
on the country’s debts — meaning it will be broke again within two
years. Meanwhile,
there are doom-laden warnings that the collapse of the Greek economy
could be the catalyst for another global recession.
Perhaps
if the Greeks themselves had shown more willingness to tighten their
belts and pay taxes due to the state, voters across Europe might not
now be feeling such anger towards them.
But
having strolled the streets of Kifissia, and watched the Greek hordes
stream past the honesty boxes on the underground, it does not take a
degree in European economics to know when somebody is taking advantage
— at our expense.
|